- What % of people would prefer a prestigious degree without having to attend classes.
- Vs what % would prefer the classes of the prestigious colleges or universities without caring for the degree.
He chose two of the most sought after institutions:
- The IITs (Indian Institute of Technology)
- And the IIMs (Indian Institute of Management)
We did a statistical analysis of the above results, and found interesting insights. In simple words, the conclusions are:
- Almost equal share of people have the primary motivation to learn(not degree) vs degree(not learn)
- Overall more people prefered IIMs over IITs ( both above motivations considered together)
- Among those whose primary motivation is degree(not learning), they have a stronger preference towards IITs over IIMs - indicating IITs have a higher brand value compared to IIMs.
- Among those whose primary motivation is learning(not degree), they have a stronger preference towards IIMs over IITs - indicating subjects at IIMs are seen as more relevant topics to learn. This is a point of introspection for IITs.
The detailed analysis with step by step "tutorial like" explanation is given below.
Step by step tutorial:
We will analyse the responses of the survey by first breaking it down in to the the factors considered in the experiments. We have two factors (degree and primary motivation) and each of the factors have two levels as follows:
- Primary Motivation
- Degree w/o Classes (Read Degree is more important than learning provided in the institutions)
- Classes w/o Degree (Read learning is more important than the degree)
Structuring the data from the survey would look something like this in Minitab worksheet.
Now, to analyse this data, we will fit it into a general linear model, using the command flow below:
Stat > ANOVA > General Linear Model > Fit general Linear Model
Then select the responses and factors as follows:
Go to Models, and select both "degree" and "Primary motivation", set interaction through order = 2 and click add. The Degree*Primary Motivation term will get added to the model.
Then click ok, then ok again. Now the model is built within Minitab. Now go to:
Stat > ANOVA > General Linear Model > Factorial Plots
In terms to display, select "All Terms", and click ok. You will get two graphs. Thee first one is the main effect plot. This plot analyzes the relative effect of each of the factors, resulting in variation in the response.
- The right plot - almost equal % of people have the primary motivation of classes (not degree) vs degree(not classes)
- The left plot - compared to factor of "primary motivation", in case of the "degree" factor - remarkably higher % of people have a preference towards IIMs over IITs.
- Opinion: This could be more representative of people responding on Linkedin, (sampling non-homogeneity).
- Suggest similar study using a different medium, for example via tele-calling.
Now, the other graph generated is called interaction plot. This plot analyzes, the effect of one factor, keeping the level of another factor constant.
- The red line indicates that those who have a primary motivation of degree(not classes) prefer IITs over IIMs. Given that overall the preference to IIMs was higher, there seems to be a strong bias towards IITs by people who just want to get the degree(not classes)
- The blue line indicates that those who have a primary motivation of learning, i.e classes(not degree), prefer IIMs over IITs.
Opinion(purely mine, don't blame statistics if you disagree with me):
- If the sampling is truly random, this is a pretty interesting insight.
- It seems, IITs have a higher brand value compared to IIMs, however, more people think the subjects taught at IITs aren't as relevant or have practical significance.
- This should be a point of introspection for the IITs.Please re-look in to the academic curriculum.
- Are the IITs grossly under-utilizing 4-5 years of the most brilliant students you filter though JEE?
- Are the IITs' subjects relevant to today's context?
- It also seems that more people value the learning (or maybe networking) opportunity at IIMs than at IITs, however, the brand value of IIMs lag behind IITs.
- This should be a point of introspection for MBA aspirants.
- Go there for learning (or for networking - but its a bad idea during recession like times)
- Aspirants who think IIMs will give then a good "brand value" to compete with IITians - sorry, IIMs are not yet there! Better to focus on learning or networking, that will help 😛
For the statistically-correct type
Yeah, I assumed a discrete (count) response as continuous and modeled it, which is not perfect! I may not have used the perfect statistical tool for the analysis. But if you were to do a chi-square test for association (which I think is more difficult for people to understand), your interpretations wouldn't have change! Here it is for you to mull.
Hope you enjoyed this. Appreciate your comments!